Score: 8

"Great sequel"

submission: Madness Consternation

date: May 7, 2007

Funny how I keep coming back to this website soon enough after you release an episode for it to be on the front page.

This was a good episode; I think it was better than the last, with an only slightly ambiguous ending that's a lot more fitting. The animation and background design is a lot more polish and interesting, too. Good work.

Score: 6

"Good art"

submission: MGS 3: Crab Battle

date: August 29, 2006

First the good: The art was well drawn and fairly well-colored. The hacker was a good touch, too.

But the animation was minimal, mainly a kind of South Park style restricted movement, with almost no adherence to physics (cartoon or "real"). Making all the body parts separate pieces and just using tweening didn't help. The front view shot of Snake moving down the hallway didn't say "crawling", it said "floating while cracking knucles." Probably not what you were going for there.

And the voice acting. The girl wasn't too bad, but YOU CAN NOT ACT. Saying everything through clenched teeth does not make it more dramatic; it just makes you harder to understand. You also seem to have no idea what a lot of the lines mean, because you consistely say them with the wrong emphasis and/or tone of voice.

The stone in the tunnel doesn't move at the same speed as the floor and rest of the tunnel, either. That kind of bothered me.

Score: 7

"Nice round robin animation"

submission: Switchit

date: February 25, 2006

These were all clearly made by good artists as well as animators. Very nice multi-artist flash.